Trinity Street Capital Partners-Private Equity | Commercial Mortgages| Multifamily Lending

As President Donald Trump embarks on his second term in 2025, his administration’s immigration policies are poised to significantly influence various sectors of the U.S. economy, including commercial real estate (CRE). With proposals centered on mass deportations, tightened border security, and restrictions on both legal and undocumented immigration, these policies could reshape labor markets, construction costs, housing demand, and investor confidence in CRE. This article explores the multifaceted effects of Trump’s immigration agenda on the commercial real estate industry, drawing on economic analyses, expert insights, and market trends to provide a comprehensive outlook.

Immigration Policies: A Recap of Trump’s Agenda

 

During his 2024 campaign and early second term, Trump has emphasized aggressive immigration reforms. Key proposals include:

 

  • Mass Deportations: Plans to deport millions of undocumented immigrants, potentially targeting both those with criminal records and broader groups, with statements suggesting entire families could be removed to avoid separation.
  • Border Security: Executive orders signed on day one to curb migration across U.S. borders, including enhanced enforcement and restrictions on asylum processes.
  • Restrictions on Legal Immigration: Proposals to limit visa programs, such as H-1B and investor visas, which could affect skilled workers and international investors. Posts on X indicate a decline in investor visa applications and international buyer activity in markets like Miami.
  • Workforce Implications: Policies that could reduce the availability of immigrant labor, particularly in industries like construction, hospitality, and manufacturing, which rely heavily on migrant workers.

 

These policies, combined with a Republican-controlled Congress, are likely to face fewer legislative hurdles, increasing the probability of implementation. However, their execution remains uncertain, as Trump’s first term saw some immigration promises moderated or stalled by legal and practical challenges.

Impacts on Commercial Real Estate

 

The CRE sector, encompassing office, retail, industrial, multifamily, and hospitality properties, is highly sensitive to economic shifts driven by policy changes. Trump’s immigration policies could affect CRE through several key channels: labor availability, construction costs, housing demand, and investor sentiment.

  1. Construction Labor Shortages and Rising Costs

The construction industry, a cornerstone of CRE development, relies heavily on immigrant labor. Approximately 30% of the U.S. construction workforce is comprised of immigrants, with a significant portion being undocumented. In regions like the Sun Belt, including Raleigh and Miami, immigrant workers have been critical to maintaining affordable housing and commercial development.

  • Impact of Deportations: Mass deportations could drastically reduce the construction labor pool, leading to labor shortages and higher wages. Experts estimate that such policies could increase construction costs by driving up labor expenses, particularly in labor-intensive sectors like multifamily and industrial development.
  • Regional Variations: Markets with high concentrations of immigrant workers, such as gateway cities (e.g., Miami, Los Angeles, New York), are particularly vulnerable. For instance, a study by the Migration Policy Institute estimates Wake County, North Carolina, has 41,000 undocumented immigrants, many of whom work in construction.
  • Mitigation Efforts: Some analysts suggest that streamlining legal immigration for skilled workers could offset labor shortages, but Trump’s current rhetoric leans toward broader restrictions, making this less likely in the near term.

Higher construction costs could delay or derail CRE projects, particularly in cost-sensitive sectors like affordable housing and retail. Developers may face longer timelines and reduced project feasibility, potentially stifling new supply in already tight markets.

 

  1. Housing Demand and Multifamily Markets

Immigration policies also influence housing demand, a critical driver for the multifamily CRE sector. Undocumented immigrants and migrant workers often occupy workforce housing (Class B and C apartments), particularly in gateway markets.

 

  • Reduced Demand in Workforce Housing: Marcus & Millichap CEO Hessam Nadji notes that mass deportations could significantly reduce demand for workforce housing in cities like Miami, New York, and Los Angeles, where immigrant populations are substantial. This could lead to higher vacancy rates in lower-tier multifamily properties, impacting rental income for investors.
  • Short-Term vs. Long-Term Effects: While reduced immigration might temporarily ease housing demand, academic research from the University of Utah and other institutions suggests that deportations do not significantly alleviate affordability pressures. Instead, the loss of construction labor exacerbates supply constraints, pushing up prices over time.
  • Miami’s Unique Challenges: Miami, a hub for international buyers and immigrant renters, is already experiencing a CRE slowdown due to high mortgage rates and insurance costs. Trump’s immigration crackdown has reportedly deterred international buyers, with luxury agents in Brickell noting a two-thirds drop in international transactions since February 2025.

These dynamics suggest that multifamily investors in immigrant-heavy markets should brace for potential revenue declines, while developers may struggle to meet demand due to labor constraints.

 

  1. Industrial and Warehousing: Mixed Outcomes

The industrial CRE sector, including warehouses and logistics facilities, could see both opportunities and challenges from immigration policies, particularly when combined with Trump’s proposed tariffs.

  • Tariff-Driven Stockpiling: Trump’s proposed tariffs (e.g., 25% on Mexico and Canada, 60% on China) could prompt businesses to hoard materials, boosting demand for industrial outdoor storage (IOS) and warehousing space. This could be a tailwind for industrial CRE, especially in domestic supply chains.
  • Labor Constraints: However, reduced immigrant labor could increase operational costs for industrial tenants, particularly in manufacturing and logistics, where immigrants make up a significant portion of the workforce. Higher costs may be passed on to consumers, potentially dampening long-term demand for industrial space.
  • Geographic Shifts: Warehouses near seaports and borders may face headwinds due to trade disruptions, while those in domestic supply chains could benefit from protectionist policies.

Industrial CRE investors should monitor tariff implementation and labor market trends to assess whether short-term demand spikes outweigh long-term cost pressures.

 

  1. Hospitality and Retail: Cost Pressures and Consumer Spending

 

The hospitality and retail CRE sectors, which depend on immigrant labor and consumer spending, could face significant challenges.

  • Labor Costs in Hospitality: The hospitality industry relies on immigrants for roles such as housekeeping and food service. Curbed immigration could increase labor costs, squeezing margins for hotel operators and potentially leading to higher lease rates or reduced profitability for hospitality CRE owners.
  • Retail Vulnerabilities: Retail properties, particularly those serving immigrant communities, may see reduced foot traffic if deportations decrease local populations. Additionally, higher tariffs could raise consumer goods prices, curbing spending and affecting retail tenant performance.
  • Economic Context: While Trump’s tax cuts and deregulation may boost consumer spending in the short term, inflationary pressures from immigration restrictions and tariffs could offset these gains, creating uncertainty for retail and hospitality CRE.

 

  1. Investor Sentiment and International Investment

 

Trump’s immigration policies could also influence CRE investment patterns, particularly for international investors.

  • Decline in International Buyers: In Miami, posts on X report that even legal visa holders are hesitant to invest due to the immigration crackdown, with developers noting thinner pipelines and reduced investor visa applications. This trend could extend to other gateway markets, reducing capital inflows for CRE projects.
  • Opportunity Zones Revival: On the positive side, the Trump administration’s focus on reviving the Opportunity Zone program, which drove $75 billion in investments during his first term, could attract domestic and international capital to distressed areas.
  • Pro-Business Environment: A pro-business regulatory environment, including potential extensions of the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, could enhance investor confidence. Features like pass-through income deductions and accelerated depreciation have historically favored CRE investments.

Investors will need to weigh these opportunities against risks like inflation and labor shortages when planning their CRE strategies.

Broader Economic Context: Inflation and Interest Rates

 

 

Trump’s immigration policies do not operate in isolation; they intersect with other economic factors, such as tariffs and fiscal policy, which could amplify their impact on CRE.

  • Inflationary Pressures: Restrictive immigration policies are widely viewed as inflationary, as they reduce labor supply and increase wages. Combined with tariffs, these policies could drive up construction and operational costs, potentially leading to higher commercial property cap rates and lower valuations.
  • Interest Rate Dynamics: Higher inflation may prevent the Federal Reserve from cutting interest rates, keeping borrowing costs elevated for CRE developers and investors. Moody’s predicts the 10-year Treasury yield will remain in the 4% to 5% range, creating headwinds for CRE development.
  • Fiscal Stimulus: Tax cuts and deregulation could stimulate economic growth, boosting demand for office and industrial space. However, increased deficits from tax cuts could push interest rates higher, offsetting these benefits.

CRE professionals must navigate this complex interplay of policies, balancing short-term growth opportunities with long-term risks.

Strategic Considerations for CRE Stakeholders

 

Given the uncertainties surrounding Trump’s immigration policies, CRE investors, developers, and managers should adopt proactive strategies to mitigate risks and capitalize on opportunities:

  • Monitor Policy Developments: Stay informed about immigration policy implementation, as the scale and scope of deportations remain uncertain. Engage with industry groups like the National Association of Home Builders or the Real Estate Roundtable for updates.
  • Diversify Portfolios: Focus on sectors less vulnerable to labor shortages, such as industrial properties benefiting from tariff-driven demand. Consider markets with lower reliance on immigrant labor or strong domestic investment.
  • Leverage Incentives: Capitalize on potential Opportunity Zone extensions and tax benefits from the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act to enhance returns on CRE investments.
  • Assess Financing Strategies: With interest rates likely to remain elevated, explore fixed-rate loans or alternative financing to lock in costs. Evaluate banking regulation changes that could affect CRE lending conditions.
  • Plan for Cost Increases: Budget for higher construction and operational costs due to labor shortages and tariffs. Prioritize projects with strong cash flows to withstand inflationary pressures.

A Final Word: Navigating a Complex Landscape

 

President Trump’s immigration policies present a mixed bag for the commercial real estate industry. While deregulation and tax incentives could spur development and investment, restrictive immigration measures threaten to increase construction costs, reduce housing demand, and disrupt labor-intensive sectors like hospitality and retail. The interplay of these policies with tariffs and fiscal stimulus adds further complexity, potentially driving inflation and interest rates higher.

 

CRE stakeholders must adopt a cautious yet opportunistic approach, closely monitoring policy developments and economic indicators. By diversifying investments, leveraging incentives, and planning for cost increases, investors and developers can navigate the challenges and capitalize on the opportunities presented by Trump’s second term. As Matt Anderson of Anderson Legal aptly noted, “It’s easy to jump to conclusions, but every election cycle brings new unknowns. The best strategy is to monitor policy changes closely and adjust investment plans accordingly.”

 

The CRE industry stands at a pivotal moment, and adaptability will be key to thriving in this evolving landscape.

 

 

Trinity Street Capital Partners-Private Equity | Commercial Mortgages| Multifamily Lending